DB8 Speech & Debate Academy
Unit 4 · Lesson 1 5 min

Source Hierarchy

Not all sources are equal. Judges weight them differently — know the pecking order.

Tier 1 — gold

Peer-reviewed studies (Nature, JAMA), official government data (CBO, GAO, BLS), and major nonpartisan think tanks (Brookings, RAND, Pew).

Tier 2 — solid

Major newspapers (NYT, WSJ, Reuters, AP), university research centers, established industry reports.

Tier 3 — risky

Opinion pieces, partisan think tanks (Heritage, CAP), blog posts. Use only with disclosure.

Tier 4 — don't

Wikipedia, random YouTube, AI-generated summaries without source check.

Quick Check
  1. 1. Strongest source for a policy stat:

Answer all 1 to check.

Takeaway

Tier 1 sources let you stop arguments cold. Tier 4 sources lose them.