DB8 Speech & Debate Academy
Bills Library

Practice bills

Every bill is sorted by grade band and skill level — pick the row that matches you. Built in, no outside sites required.

← All bills
H.R. 1109·High School Experienced

A Bill to Expand the Supreme Court to 13 Justices

Rep. Edwards (D-NY)

Adds four seats to the Supreme Court over a single presidential term.

Sec. 1 — Mandate

The Supreme Court shall consist of 13 Associate Justices and one Chief Justice.

Sec. 2 — Phase-In

The President shall nominate one additional justice per year for four years following enactment.

Sec. 3 — Funding

$28 million for chambers and staff.

Sec. 4 — Enforcement

Senate advise-and-consent procedure.

Tournament Prep

Mechanical parts, sourced & timed

Use this as your pre-round checklist. Memorize the source citation. Time yourself to the delivery target.

Bill / Number
H.R. 1109 — A Bill to Expand the Supreme Court to 13 Justices
Funding source
$28M for chambers and staff.
Timeline
4-year phased nomination process.
Realistic mechanically; politically explosive.
Enforcing agency
Senate advise-and-consent procedure.
Yes — Article III §1 leaves Court size to Congress (Judiciary Act of 1869 set 9).
Penalty for non-compliance
N/A — structural change.
Source citation
Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court of the United States (2021), 'Final Report' — whitehouse.gov.
Delivery time (read aloud)
1:10 (70s)
Strongest counter-argument

Expansion sets a tit-for-tat precedent — the next majority adds 4 more seats, destroying judicial legitimacy.

Your pre-emptive answer

The 2021 Presidential Commission's report addressed this directly — the strongest safeguard is statutory expansion paired with term-limit reform (a related bill). And the legitimacy concern cuts both ways: Gallup (2023) shows Court approval at 40%, the lowest in polling history; the status quo is already legitimacy-eroding.