DB8 Speech & Debate Academy
Bills Library

Practice bills

Every bill is sorted by grade band and skill level — pick the row that matches you. Built in, no outside sites required.

← All bills
S. 401·High School Experienced

A Bill to Establish a National Carbon Tax with Dividend

Sen. Mwangi (D-IL)

Imposes a $45/ton carbon tax at point of extraction, rising $10/year. 70% of revenue is rebated quarterly to households.

Sec. 1 — Mandate

A tax of $45 per metric ton of CO2-equivalent shall be levied at point of extraction or import, increasing $10 annually.

Sec. 2 — Dividend

70% of net revenue shall be rebated equally to U.S. households on a quarterly basis.

Sec. 3 — Border Adjustment

Imports from countries without an equivalent carbon price shall pay a border adjustment fee.

Sec. 4 — Enforcement

Administered by the IRS in coordination with the EPA.

Tournament Prep

Mechanical parts, sourced & timed

Use this as your pre-round checklist. Memorize the source citation. Time yourself to the delivery target.

Bill / Number
S. 401 — A Bill to Establish a National Carbon Tax with Dividend
Funding source
Tax revenue from extraction-point levy; 70% returned as dividend.
Timeline
Effective FY27.
Realistic — British Columbia (2008) and Canada federal (2019) implemented in 18 months.
Enforcing agency
IRS + EPA.
Yes — IRS administers excise taxes; EPA measures emissions.
Penalty for non-compliance
Excise tax non-compliance + CAA citizen-suit overlay.
Source citation
Climate Leadership Council, Akerlof & Mankiw et al. (2019), 'Economists' Statement on Carbon Dividends' — clcouncil.org (signed by 28 Nobel laureates).
Delivery time (read aloud)
1:15 (75s)
Strongest counter-argument

A carbon tax is regressive — energy costs hit low-income households hardest.

Your pre-emptive answer

The 70% dividend in Sec. 2 is precisely the fix — Citizens' Climate Lobby (2023) modeled equal-per-household rebates and found the bottom 70% of households are *net beneficiaries*. Regressivity is a function of design choice, not the tax itself.