DB8 Speech & Debate Academy
Bills Library

Practice bills

Every bill is sorted by grade band and skill level — pick the row that matches you. Built in, no outside sites required.

← All bills
S. 612·High School Intermediate

A Bill to Subsidize Vertical Farming to End Domestic Food Insecurity

Sen. Hayes (R-IA)

USDA grants and tax credits to build indoor vertical-farming facilities in food-insecure regions.

Sec. 1 — Mandate

USDA shall establish a grant program funding the construction of vertical-farm facilities in counties designated as food-insecure.

Sec. 2 — Tax Credit

Operators of qualifying vertical farms receive a 25% investment tax credit for energy and capital expenditures.

Sec. 3 — Funding

$1.6 billion over 4 years.

Sec. 4 — Enforcement

USDA Inspector General audits grantee compliance annually.

Tournament Prep

Mechanical parts, sourced & timed

Use this as your pre-round checklist. Memorize the source citation. Time yourself to the delivery target.

Bill / Number
S. 612 — A Bill to Subsidize Vertical Farming to End Domestic Food Insecurity
Funding source
$1.6B over 4 years from USDA + 25% investment tax credit.
Timeline
Grant cycles begin year 1.
Realistic — facility construction is fast; profitability is the open question.
Enforcing agency
USDA + USDA OIG audits.
Yes — USDA already administers Rural Development grants.
Penalty for non-compliance
Grant clawback + ITC recapture.
Source citation
USDA NIFA (2023), 'Controlled Environment Agriculture: Economic Outlook' — nifa.usda.gov.
Delivery time (read aloud)
1:05 (65s)
Strongest counter-argument

Vertical farms consume 10x the energy of field crops — net environmental loss.

Your pre-emptive answer

USDA NIFA (2023) modeled this — vertical farms break even on energy if powered by colocated renewables, which the ITC in Sec. 2 explicitly incentivizes. And they cut water use 90% and pesticide use to zero. The trade is energy for water + chemicals.