DB8 Speech & Debate Academy
Bills Library

Practice bills

Every bill is sorted by grade band and skill level — pick the row that matches you. Built in, no outside sites required.

← All bills
H.R. 1268·High School Experienced

A Bill to Preempt Single-Family-Only Zoning Near Transit

Rep. Sato (D-CA)

Federal preemption of single-family-only zoning within a half-mile of fixed-rail transit stations.

Sec. 1 — Mandate

Localities receiving any federal transit or housing funds shall permit multifamily housing of at least four units by right within 0.5 miles of fixed-rail transit stations.

Sec. 2 — Preemption

Conflicting local zoning rules are preempted within the defined radius.

Sec. 3 — Funding

$310 million in technical assistance and litigation support.

Sec. 4 — Enforcement

HUD and DOT joint enforcement.

Tournament Prep

Mechanical parts, sourced & timed

Use this as your pre-round checklist. Memorize the source citation. Time yourself to the delivery target.

Bill / Number
H.R. 1268 — A Bill to Preempt Single-Family-Only Zoning Near Transit
Funding source
$310M from HUD + DOT technical assistance.
Timeline
Effective at next federal grant cycle (12 months).
Realistic — California SB 9 (2021) shows state-level rollout in 9 months.
Enforcing agency
HUD + DOT joint enforcement.
Yes — both routinely condition funding (South Dakota v. Dole, 1987).
Penalty for non-compliance
Withholding of federal transit + housing grants.
Source citation
Furman Center (NYU, 2023), 'Zoning, Land Use, and Housing Supply' — furmancenter.org.
Delivery time (read aloud)
1:15 (75s)
Strongest counter-argument

Federal zoning preemption violates the Tenth Amendment and local democratic control.

Your pre-emptive answer

It doesn't preempt — it *conditions federal funds*, which South Dakota v. Dole (1987) settled. Localities remain free to keep their zoning if they decline transit and housing grants. Furman Center (2023) showed exclusionary zoning around transit costs $1.6T in cumulative GDP and is itself the result of decades of non-democratic redlining; the federal corrective is well-grounded.