DB8 Speech & Debate Academy
Bills Library

Practice bills

Every bill is sorted by grade band and skill level — pick the row that matches you. Built in, no outside sites required.

← All bills
H.R. 612·Elementary Experienced

A Bill to Establish a National Phonics-Based Reading Standard for K-3

Rep. Murray (R-UT)

Conditions federal literacy funds on adoption of evidence-based structured-literacy curricula in K-3.

Sec. 1 — Mandate

States receiving Comprehensive Literacy State Development grants shall adopt a structured-literacy core curriculum for K-3 reading by FY28.

Sec. 2 — Approved List

The Institute of Education Sciences maintains a list of qualifying curricula.

Sec. 3 — Funding

$1.4 billion for curriculum adoption, teacher coaching, and assessment.

Sec. 4 — Enforcement

Non-compliant states forfeit literacy formula funds.

Tournament Prep

Mechanical parts, sourced & timed

Use this as your pre-round checklist. Memorize the source citation. Time yourself to the delivery target.

Bill / Number
H.R. 612 — A Bill to Establish a National Phonics-Based Reading Standard for K-3
Funding source
$1.4B from ED Comprehensive Literacy State Development grants.
Timeline
Compliance by FY28.
Realistic — Mississippi and Tennessee implemented in 3-4 years.
Enforcing agency
Institute of Education Sciences + ED.
Yes — IES already curates evidence-based programs.
Penalty for non-compliance
Forfeiture of literacy formula funds.
Source citation
NAEP / Hanford (APM Reports, 2022), 'Sold a Story' + NCES literacy data — nces.ed.gov.
Delivery time (read aloud)
1:05 (65s)
Strongest counter-argument

Federal mandates on curriculum violate the Tenth Amendment.

Your pre-emptive answer

This conditions *grant* dollars, not state authority — states remain free to decline. SCOTUS upheld this exact spending-clause mechanism in South Dakota v. Dole (1987).